In reply to: Interesting stuff - I wasn't aware of pre Daugherty history posted by ndhouston
Miami's main problem is that there isn't anything to it: it's just the same few bars repeated a few times.
I agree that FSU's is pretty bad.
The MSU one strikes me as just a fairly ordinary early-twentieth-century fight song melody. Not on par with ours or Texas A&M's, but not an epochal affront to music.
PSU's is dumb and clownish, but not especially annoying. FSU's is nothing special either way. Of course, there's a special place in hell for their infernal tomahawk chop.