Seems personal. Kind of bizarre, honestly.

Even assuming you have good insider information that you don't want to share (which, of course, turned out not to apply at all in the context of his recent injury), that you want to keep going after him--for what, exactly?--is very odd.

At worst, according to you, he is a student-athlete who came to Notre Dame and isn't physically or mentally "tough." Again, this alleged flaw has nothing to do with his recent injury, which no amount of "toughness" would have prevented. In any event, it's not like he's trying to hurt the team to throw games or doesn't care or something. At worst, he's fragile. At best, of course, he's someone who loves Notre Dame and his teammates but has had a bit of bad luck. And you keep on pointing to his "flaw" (which you apparently have sources for) and minimizing his contributions and showing us how little you respect or appreciate him.

It's kind of weird. Honestly, what do you hope to gain by continuing to badmouth him? Seems like the kind of thing that isn't worth continuing to bring up in threads about him, particularly when he's trying to return quickly from a serious injury to help his teammates. Did he do something to you personally? Someone close to you?